Thursday, January 20, 2011

Villaggio Pizzeria and Restaurant: "This one is pretty all over the place."


I really like the look and feel of Villagio. The kind of ramshackle, formerly fancy awning that is just filthy and tired from looking out onto Avenue C for however many years. I'd guess from the facade and the font on the top that the place has been here for a while, but I'm not an expert. And even if it opened in 1991, that's still 20 years ago! Sheesh. It kind of reminds me of the Jewish Bakery out by my grandparent's old house in Rosedale. Not that this place seems at all Jewish, just that it seems like it is a holdover from the era when even proletarian establishments seemed to want to cultivate at least an air of respectability and class. To stick with my analogy, it kind of reminds me of some of my grandmother's costume jewelry. It seems kind of gaudy and obviously fake to the real fancy-pantses (POP QUIZ HOT SHOT: what is Slice Harvester's stance on fancy-pantsing?), or maybe even to most other adults, but to children and other old people, it made her look kind of elegant. And even those who could tell that the pearls were fake still had a sense of the dignity and charisma, and knew that she SHOULD'VE been wearing real pearls.


This pizza was not so good. The dough was alright, but the cheese was so cheap and the sauce was disgusting. Matthew said it reminded him of Cici's pizza, a Southern all-you-can-eat pizza chain which Matt described as "the secret indulgence of forest activists and woodland crusties who've just been in the woods for three and a half months chaining themselves to stuff and living in tree sits eating dried beans and rice. And then they come out with The Hunger and secretly head to a Cici's and stuff themselves with pizza for three and a half hours. This place tastes like that.

"So I guess the only reason to eat here would be if you somehow found yourself caught up in a subway tunnel for a week and a half subsisting on garbage and somehow tunneled your way out onto Avenue C." Although Noah was quick to add that you'd probably have to tunnel directly ino Villaggio's basement because if you came out on the street "you'd have options," and you probably wouldn't choose this place.

But we all agreed that there was something comforting and pleasant about this slice.

Rating:


Villagio Pizzeria and Restaurant - $2.25
180 Ave C (11th & 12th)
New York, NY 10009

Tuesday, January 18, 2011

11B Express: "This is an alright slice!"


This place ain't bad. I am not in the best mood right now, so this review may be a little lackluster, but don't blame the pizza, the pizza is fine. Not great, but good. The place is a total whatever. Just a counter and some stools, not especially charming or not charming, just kind of 'eh.' But like I said, the pizza was alright.

I forgot to take a picture of the pizza here. This picture is from their website.
This was a perfect good-side-of-average slice. It had quality ingredients and decent ratios, and was really greasy. But the dough was a little soggy from all that grease and the crust was dense and brittle without being crisp. But the quality of the ingredients made it totally enjoyable, if not FUCKING AMAZING. Don't not come here. But also don't walk more than a block out of your way for this slice.

Rating:


11B Express - $2.50
174 Ave B (at 11th)
New York, NY 10009

Monday, January 17, 2011

Breaking pizza news! Ray's v. 99¢ Fresh!

I'll fill this post in with pictures and more details later tonight, I just got called in for a work emergency. But for the record, in case anyone urgently needs to know what I think about Ray's dropping their slice down to 75 cents to compete with a dollar slice place across the street: I approve. I'm sitting at Ray's right now, I've just eaten at both planes and Ray's wins this one by a long shot. More details tonight after I take care of this situation at work.

-------

I'm not sure if you guys saw the giant pizza-shaped light in the sky last night, Mayor Bloomberg was responsible, he was shining the Slice Signal to get my attention. I noticed, of course, because I was out mooning myself on my roof. Luckily there is a baked bean can in my room with a string through the bottom that leads directly to the tomato soup can in the Mayors office, so I got on the horn and quickly found out that there was a war going on in Midtown and he needed my peace-keeping efforts. So first thing this afternoon, after awakening from my daily siesta, I mounted the saddle of my riding ostrich and headed into the Very Civilized Burough of Manhattan to tend to the crisis.

And what a crisis it was! Famous Original Ray's was flying its war flag:


75¢ Pizza Slices! Run! Hide! Actually in typical shitty F.O.R. fashion, they charge tax on their 75¢ slice. So just like their "$2.75" slice is actually $3.00, their 75¢ slice is actually 82¢. But that's still really cheap so I'll stop complaining there.


Okay, this slice wasn't so bad, and for 82¢ it fucking RULED. This is the first sub-$1 slice of pizza I've ever had that I don't feel compelled to put in a separate category. This is actual pizza! And Ray's cheapened their operation by making their slices a lot smaller, not by skimping on the ingredients, which are still totally mid-grade. The funny thing is, my big beef with Ray's in the past has been that their slices have always been too doughy to cook properly. The crazy reality is that by dropping their price, and the size of their slice, they have actually made their pizza better! Kudos to you, congratulations. The only drawback is, of course, that this is a F.O.R. slice, so the sauce tastes like total crap. But it's easy to drown that in garlic powder or whatever and then this still rules for the price. I'm not sure how long this deal is going to last, but it's a good one.


99¢ Fresh Pizza across the street did not seem to be fairing well in the face of their competition. When I went inside there everyone seemed really depressed and bummed out. And I can see why. The pizza they are serving is garbage!


This slice was also tiny. It had that crappy frozen-dough flavor of most dollar places, and the weird unplaceable aftertaste in the sauce that tastes like a fart. This is pizza I wouldn't be BUMMED to eat on tour, but wouldn't be thrilled about either. It wasn't terribly offensive, and it only cost a buck, but it objectively wasn't very good.

I came into this crisis siding with 99¢ Fresh Pizza. There is something I like about them. They are the scrappy underdog. Famous Original Ray's is the shitty bully. I have unabashedly harshed on FOR since the beginning of Slice Harvester for serving shit pizza, and I have always backed 99¢ Fresh as a model that I like. At least they are trying at a populist approach to food, even if they fall short. But I have to admit, even as an virulent Ray's basher and ardent 99¢ Fresh supporter, Ray's wins this one by a long shot. I am thinking about the slice I had there today and it was actually GOOD. I think it might've been the first good slice I've ever had at a Famous Original Ray's.

Friday, January 14, 2011

Muzzarella: "No thank you."


Cory had mentioned that Muzzarella was alright, and it was really packed when we walked by, so me and Matt and Noah were pretty excited about eating here. I mean, as a pizzeria, it looked good! Tiny and cramped, overflowing with people, there was barely room for the three of us and I felt a brief tinge of guilt for taking up a table and only ordering 1 slice. But then we got our pizza and I realized that we were doing a favor to anyone who decided not to come in because we were taking up too much room.


Goodness gracious! This slice was a real waste. It had that criss-cross diamond screen pattern on the bottom where you can tell it was made on top of one of those weird cafeteria trays that looks like a giant bong screen. And it didn't taste like anything really, although Noah said, "this tastes like cans." Matt said the grease didn't taste like anything and the crust tasted like a cracker, which I agree with. And it crumbled in this way totally stunk. All in all this slice was the pits and I knew that already from hanging out in this neighborhood in ages past, but I had totally forgotten cause it's been so long.

Rating:


Muzzarella - $2.25
221 Ave A (13th & 14th)
New York, NY 10009

Thursday, January 13, 2011

Iggy's: "Here comes my chinese rug."


Iggy's! In case you didn't catch it, my title is a reference to the Iggy Pop song Success from 1977's Lust for Life album:


Briefly, I would like to mention a second-hand Iggy Pop story. Prior to the decree that everyone at airports had to take their shoes off, my friend Sal was flying to the DR and was on the same plane as Iggy (literally, although not figuratively!). Sal noticed Iggy waiting because he was wearing a sport coat with no shirt underneath and only had one shoe on. Iggy was hanging out with a portly, spoiled-looking teenager who Sal presumed to be his son, and when the plane boarded, Sal noticed that Iggy was flying first class but had booked his kid in coach! I guess it's easier to blast off on success without your kid cramping your style.


Anyway, back to Iggy's Pizza. This place has a stellar slice! It is a bit wet, but in a good way. Noah took a bite and said, "that is... JUICY!" very excitedly. It was soft and wet without being soggy or underdone. It had the perfect amount of good grease and totally delicious chewy crust. Not overly chewy, mind you, but chewy like great homemade bread. It just tasted very personal, if that makes sense, like a lot of love went into it's preparation.

Rating:

Iggy's  - $2.50
173 1st Ave (12th & 13th)
New York, NY 10003

Wednesday, January 12, 2011

Vinny Vincenz: "This is good pizza!"


Slice Harvester correspondent Cory Feierman--record store manager, dream-babe rock'n'roller, pizza lover, punk rocker--has long mentioned to me that he is pretty into the slice at Vinny Vincenz, although last Thursday when we went by Academy to say hello to him, he was quick to mention that the slice there is usually hit or miss. Luckily for Matthew, Noah and I, or slice last week was a huge hit.


This slice was well cooked and had great ratios. It was a noisy slice. It snapped and cracked when bitten or folded, but it wasn't brittle, just delicately crisp. It had good cheese and an excellent charred flavor, though it was a tad on the small side. Matthew said, "the thinness of the crust demonstrates a measured skill," and I couldn't agree more. But heed the words of Cory, apparently we were lucky and this slice is usually all over the map.

Rating:


Vinny Vincenz - $2.50
231 1st Ave (13th & 14th)
New York, NY 10003